A lowball offer can feel like a slap in the face, but it is often just a negotiating tactic. Learn how to read it and respond from a position of strength.

By Katie DeWitt

Katie got into real estate in 2013, starting on the title and escrow side, where she learned how deals actually come together, the fine print, the timelines, and the small things that can make or break a transaction.

Get the Most from Your Next Move. Start with a casual chat to craft a plan as unique as your story. Book a Call

You open the offer on your home, and the number is nowhere close to what you expected. Your first thought is simple. Are they even serious? A low offer can feel like a slap in the face, especially after the work you put into getting your home ready to sell. The instinct is to fire back with a flat no or walk away entirely.

That instinct is worth resisting. A lowball offer is part of the negotiation process, whether you are selling your home or making an offer on one. It is a tactic, and while it can be frustrating, it does not have to throw you off balance. The buyer is testing how flexible you are. You want a fair price. Understanding that gap is where a good response starts. Here are four ways to handle it.

1. Understand where the offer is coming from. Before you react, figure out what is driving the number. Is the buyer simply chasing the best possible deal, or do they not fully understand the local market? Sometimes a low offer is a test of your flexibility. Other times, the buyer genuinely does not realize what the property is worth. Reading between the lines gives you a starting point and the space to decide how to counter.

“A lowball offer is not where the buyer ends up. It is just where they decided to start.”

2. Stay calm and collected. A knee-jerk reaction will not help you close the deal. Whether you are the buyer or the seller, a level head keeps you from getting rattled. When you stay composed, you signal to the other party that you are in control of the situation. Appearing too eager or too upset puts you at a disadvantage. This is a business negotiation, and you hold the upper hand when you keep your cool.

3. Counter with confidence and expert guidance. This is where an experienced agent earns their keep. A lowball offer is rarely as simple as accepting, rejecting, or countering at one specific number. The right response depends on current market conditions, buyer activity, how long the property has been available, competing inventory, and the overall strength of the offer. My job is to help you read what is happening in the market right now, weigh the pros and cons of each path, and build the best strategy for your specific moment. Sometimes the smartest move is a strong counter. Sometimes it is a small adjustment. Sometimes it is holding firm. Every situation is different.

5. Know when to walk away. Some offers are not worth your time. If the number sits too far below your bottom line, it is okay to politely decline and move on. A serious buyer will often come back with something stronger once they understand you are not willing to settle for less. Walking away is not failure. It is a signal that you know your home’s value.

Handling a lowball offer comes down to four things. Understand the offer, stay calm, lean on expert guidance, and know when to walk away. If you are considering selling your home, work with an agent who knows how to read market conditions, handle negotiations, and protect your bottom line. The work starts long before an offer arrives, often with getting your home ready to sell the right way. That is where experience matters most.

If you have questions about an offer or you are thinking about selling, I would love to help. Call or text me at 503-621-6832, email me at katie@movewithdewitt.com, or visit movewithdewitt.com. I am happy to walk through your options with you.